A classic pumpkin pie recipe, made without canned evaporated milk, and made with a homemade all butter pie crust. The best part is you can make the pie ahead of time – perfect for the holidays!
My boyfriend, now husband, was devastated. He drove all the way home with me from Boston to upstate NY for Thanksgiving to find his favorite pie not on the table?! Don’t worry I redeemed myself and whipped up this Eggless Pumpkin Pie, (made with condensed milk) the next day (we were out of eggs after all our feasting but it did the trick!)
But I decided it was high time that a classic pumpkin pie recipe was on the blog and unlike traditional pumpkin pies, this recipe does not rely on evaporated milk. This pie is 100% from scratch, through and through. But you can break up the steps to make this pie over a few days if you need to. In fact I recommend it!
I like to make my pie crust a few days ahead of time, so it’s nice and cold in the fridge waiting for me. You can even blind bake the crust a few days ahead of time. Then the day before I’m ready to serve, I assemble and bake the entire pie. Pies need time to cool and set up anyway so it’s even better to make this a whole day ahead and let it cool and properly set up.
This pumpkin pie recipe starts with an all butter homemade pie crust. I’ll show you step by step how to make the best pie crust ever. No tough pie crust for you! And then an easy, no mixer required pumpkin pie filling gets poured into a partially baked pie shell.
Can you make pumpkin pie without evaporated milk?
Yes! And this pie is here to prove it. Evaporated milk is usually used in a pumpkin pie recipe because evaporated milk has 60% of the water removed which helps to create a thick, creamy texture without adding extra sweetness.
But if you’re like me you don’t always have a canned evaporated milk on hand. But the best part is you can substitute the canned milk for heavy cream or half and half instead. And that’s just what I did for this pie! I used heavy cream to make a rich, velvety smooth pumpkin pie (without any canned milk!)
Pie Crust Ingredients
Pumpkin Pie Filling Ingredients
- Brown Sugar
- Heavy Cream
- Pumpkin Puree
- Pumpkin Pie Spice
How To Make Pumpkin Pie
1. Make the pie crust
- Make the crust. In a food processor, or mixing bowl combine the flour and salt.
- Add butter pieces. Scatter butter over top. Make sure your butter is cold and cubed up so it’s easier to work in.
- Cut in the butter. You want to incorporate the butter until mixture resembles coarse cornmeal. If using a food processor, I pulse until the piece are pea-sized. If doing this by hand, then you can rub the butter between your fingertips or use a pastry cutter.
- Add ice cold water. Sprinkle 3 tablespoons of the ice water over the mixture. If making by hand, stir dough together using a spatula, until dough sticks together. Or pulse if using the food processor. Test the dough by squeezing some together with your fingertips. If it sticks together, then do not add more water. If it does not, then add the remaining tablespoon of water. Turn the dough onto a sheet of plastic wrap and flatten into a 4-inch disk. Wrap tightly in plastic wrap and refrigerate for 1 hour.
2. Blind bake the crust
For this type of pie, you want to blind bake it first, which means to partially bake the crust without any filling to it. To blind bake your crust you need something to hold down your pie crust as it bakes. Pie weights like these are a great thing to have (but hey you can also use uncooked dry rice or beans too!).
Here a complete tutorial on how to blind bake your crust. And if you want to make the edges of your crust super pretty, here are 4 fun ways to decorate your pie crust. My favorite for this pie is to use these pie cutters.
HEATHER’S BAKING Tip: I recommend you bake your pie in a glass pie plate. This will ensure you can see that the bottom of your crust is fully baked (nothing worse than a soggy bottomed crust!).
3. Make the pumpkin filling
While the pie crust is blind baking I prepare the pumpkin pie filling.
- Make the filling. In a mixing bowl, whisk together the brown sugar, cornstarch, spices, eggs, pumpkin puree, milk, and heavy cream until smooth. Pour into the prepared pie shell.
- Bake the pie. Pour into the prepared pie shell. Bake at 450oF for 15 minutes, then lower the temperature to 350oF and bake for an additional 40 minutes, or until the edges of the filling are set, but the center is still jiggly. You can place a pie shield (or aluminum foil) over the edges of the crust during baking if they are browning too much. During the baking, I prepare the topping.
How To Make This Pie Ahead Of Time
Nothing like leaving a pie to the last minute for the holidays! Talk about super stressful! I did it a few times back in the day. What was I thinking?! Making a whole Thanksgiving dinner and the pies on the actual holiday? Yea, let’s just say I didn’t enjoy that Thanksgiving very much. But I’ve learned that pies can be broken up over many days and it’s for the best (for the pie and my sanity).
- Pie Crust: You can make this up to 3 days ahead of time and keep in the fridge. You can also freeze it for 3 months!
- Blind baking: This can be done up to 3 days ahead of time as kept wrapped up on your counter.
- Filling: Prepare this the night before you want to bake the pie and keep in the fridge.
- Whole Pie: I prefer to bake this the day before I plan to enjoy it so it can set up and cool properly. I also like to whip up some homemade whipped cream the day before so it’s all ready for me!
My Thanksgiving timeline:
- Week before: Make my pie crusts and keep wrapped in the fridge (If I’m making multiple pies, I’ll do multiple batches at once.)
- Sunday: Blind bake my crust.
- Tuesday: Mix up the filling and refrigerate.
- Wednesday: Bake the pie (and make some whipped cream). And at this point it’s just a matter of pouring the filling into my partially baked crust and baking. How easy was that?!
- Thursday: Enjoy!
- Use A Glass Plate. Make sure to use a glass pie plate so you can see if your crust is browned or not. If its not browning, then move the pie to the lower third of your oven.
- Blind Bake. Blind bake your pie crust so you don’t end up with a soggy pie bottom.
- Use pumpkin puree not filling. Pumpkin pie filling mix has added sugar and spices already in it.
- Use A Pie Shield. If your pie crust edges are browning too much then be sure to cover them with a pie shield (or you can simply use some aluminum foil).
You definitely can. Just make sure to still blind bake the crust.
Yes you can. You can make the pie crust a few days ahead of time, and also blind bake up to 3 days ahead of time. I like to make mine the day before and then let it cool and you can store it in the refrigerator. You can also make the pie crust and filling separate the night before you assemble and bake.
Yes the pie freezes well for up to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator. You can also freeze just the pie crust as well.
This means your pie is undercooked, but you can pop it back in the oven. Bake the pie for another 15 minutes at 425oF.
Yes you can substitute with half and half. Or you can use milk, a lactose free milk, or plant based milk like almond milk but you will need to add 1 Tablespoon cornstarch to help thicken the pie up. I haven’t tried this method, but My Recipes recommend this substitution.
More Recipes To Try
For the crust:
- 1 1/2 cups (180g) all purpose flour
- ½ teaspoon salt
- ½ cup (1 stick, 113 g) unsalted butter, cold and cut into cubes
- 4-6 tablespoons ice water
- Make the crust. In a food processor, or mixing bowl combine the flour, sugar, and salt Scatter butter over top and cut in the butter until mixture resembles coarse cornmeal. If using a food processor, transfer mixture to a large bowl. Sprinkle 3 tablespoons of the ice water over the mixture. Stir and press dough together, using a spatula, until dough sticks together. If dough does not stick together, stir in the remaining tablespoon of water. Turn the dough onto a sheet of plastic wrap and flatten into a 4-inch disk. Wrap tightly in plastic wrap and refrigerate for 1 hour.
- Roll out the chilled pie dough. Preheat the oven to 350oF. On a floured work surface, roll out the disc of chilled dough. Turn the dough a quarter turn after every few rolls until you have a circle 12 inches in diameter. Carefully place the dough into a 9” pie dish. Tuck it in with your fingers, making sure it is smooth. Trim the excess, leaving about a 1 inch overhang. Fold the excess pie dough underneath, crimping the edges.
- Blind bake the crust. Roll out the pie dough, into a 12” circle and shape into a prepared pie plate. Line the crust with parchment paper and fill with pie weights. Bake for 15 minutes. Remove the pie weights, and dock the crust with a fork. Return to the oven and continue baking for an additional 10 minutes. Increase the oven temperature to 425°F.
- Make the filling. Combine all the filling ingredients and whisk together until smooth and combined. Pour the custard into the par-baked crust.
- Bake the pie. Place the pie onto a large baking sheet and bake for 15 minutes. Reduce the oven temperature to 350°F for 40 minutes longer, until the edges are set and the internal temperature registers 175°F.
- Cool the pie. Allow the pie to cool for 4 full hours at room temperature before serving. This time allows the filling to thicken up. Serve with vanilla ice cream if desired. Cover pie leftovers tightly and store in the refrigerator for up to 5 days.
- Storage: Store leftovers for up to 4 days, covered in the refrigerator.
- Make Ahead: You can make the pie crust a few days ahead of time, and also blind bake up to 3 days ahead of time. I like to make mine the day before and then let it cool and you can store it in the refrigerator. You can also make the pie crust and filling separate the night before you assemble and bake.
- Freezing: You can make the pie crust a few days ahead of time, and also blind bake up to 3 days ahead of time. I like to make mine the day before and then let it cool and you can store it in the refrigerator. You can also make the pie crust and filling separate the night before you assemble and bake.
- Heavy Cream: You can substitute with half and half. Or you can use milk, a lactose free milk, or plant based milk like almond milk but you will need to add 1 Tablespoon cornstarch to help thicken the pie up. I haven’t tried this method, but My Recipes recommend this substitution.
- Pumpkin: Make sure you are using pumpkin puree NOT pumpkin pie filling.
- If pie doesn’t set: This means your pie is undercooked, but you can pop it back in the oven. Bake the pie for another 15 minutes at 425oF.